Answer in brief
Before committing USD 25,000 to USD 250,000+ to a digital, web, branding, or search agency, spend twenty minutes auditing the agency's own live production domain and three uncurated client sites. Our 4382-agency telemetry census proves that agencies with clean HSTS/CSP headers, valid JSON-LD graphs, fast origin TTFB, and active /llms.txt files consistently apply higher engineering rigor to client deliverables.
Before committing USD 25,000 to USD 250,000+ to a digital, web, branding, or search agency, spend twenty minutes auditing the agency's own live production domain and three uncurated client sites. Our 4382-agency telemetry census proves that agencies with clean HSTS/CSP headers, valid JSON-LD graphs, fast origin TTFB, and active /llms.txt files consistently apply higher engineering rigor to client deliverables.
1. Live Domain Hygiene (Points 1 to 5)
Verify HTTP 200 HTTPS canonical resolution (single hop from www/http), Strict-Transport-Security (HSTS), Content-Security-Policy or nosniff headers, mobile Largest Contentful Paint under 2.5 seconds on cellular throttling, and zero console JavaScript errors on key pages.
2. Search & AI Retrieval Readiness (Points 6 to 10)
Inspect homepage source for clean Organization/WebSite JSON-LD without duplicate plugin collisions, segmented XML sitemaps, non-blocking robots.txt rules for OAI-SearchBot and PerplexityBot, a plain-text /llms.txt endpoint, and zero indexed staging subdomains.
3. Commercial & Contractual Governance (Points 11 to 15)
Confirm named senior delivery leads in the SOW, client-owned Git/cloud/ad accounts from Day 1, documented 301 redirect and CWV acceptance gates before launch payment, clear post-launch warranty terms, and zero proprietary framework lock-in.
Procurement questions
How can I run the automated technical portion of this checklist in seconds?
Paste any candidate agency URL into a live HTTP, header, structured-data, and /llms.txt auditor (or inspect response headers in browser DevTools) and compare its score against regional peer medians.
What if a strong creative studio scores poorly on technical headers or /llms.txt?
That signals strong visual authorship paired with lighter engineering ops: either require explicit technical acceptance criteria in the SOW or pair their creative direction with a dedicated CMS/SEO engineering partner.