Skip to content

How to choose a WordPress agency

WordPressBy ZenKern3 min read

Short answer

Test what an agency has built before you read its pitch. WordPress runs 2,262 of the 4,382 agency websites we checked (51.6%), but quality varies: 46.9% force a secure connection (HSTS), 42.0% publish an llms.txt file for AI search and only 5.9% publish prices. Choose an agency whose sites load fast on a phone, that builds lean themes or custom blocks, and that does not tie you to plugins of its own.

Tell engineering agencies apart from theme builders

Two very different kinds of agency both call themselves WordPress agencies. Engineering agencies such as 10up, Human Made, rtCamp, Alley, Syde, WebDevStudios and Geeklab design the data model, cache database queries, set limits on page weight and test every change on a staging site. Theme builders add dozens of unchecked plugins to a heavy commercial theme, and those sites tend to break during WordPress updates and traffic peaks.

Check three client sites before the first meeting

Before you send a brief, check three recent client sites and the agency’s own site on a phone: how fast the main content appears (Largest Contentful Paint), which security headers they send and whether their structured data is valid. Of the 4,382 agencies we checked, 3,330 (76.0%) publish structured data on their home page, 2,054 (46.9%) force a secure connection (HSTS) and 1,839 (42.0%) publish an llms.txt file.

Match the type of agency to your budget

WordPress VIP Gold agencies in New York, San Francisco and London usually price large builds from USD 75,000 to more than USD 250,000, for global media companies and very large companies. Mid-sized businesses that need custom WordPress work, a design system and SEO for USD 15,000 to USD 65,000 often get more time from senior engineers at specialist agencies in the UK outside London, Portugal (GMT+0), Canada or South Africa (GMT+2).

Put these terms in every WordPress contract

Ask for a Git repository that you own from week one, a staging site that search engines cannot index and that sends no test emails to real people, main content that appears in under 2.5 seconds on a phone on key page templates before sign-off, a complete list of 301 redirects and every plugin licence in your name.

Questions buyers ask

What is the difference between a WordPress VIP partner and an Automattic for Agencies partner?

WordPress VIP partners build large sites for media companies, governments and very large companies on the WordPress VIP platform. Automattic for Agencies Pro partners build fast managed WordPress and WooCommerce sites on Pressable and WordPress.com, mostly for mid-sized and large businesses.

How do we stop a large WordPress site from slowing down?

Ask for custom database tables with indexes for filtering, instead of searches across WordPress’s general post meta table, plus an object cache (Memcached or Redis) and a page cache that keeps pages for 24 hours.

Estimate your budget and write a brief

The budget estimator turns your type of project, size, region and currency into a budget range and a brief you can copy or download.

More buyer guides

All buyer guides